What is Polygraph and narcoanalysis Tests

What is Polygraph and narcoanalysis Tests

Polygraph and narcoanalysis tests are two distinct techniques used primarily in forensic investigations and law enforcement to assess the truthfulness of a subject’s statements. Here’s an overview of each:

1. Polygraph Test (Lie Detector Test):

  • Purpose: The polygraph test is designed to detect physiological changes in a person that may indicate deception. It is often called a “lie detector” test.
  • How It Works:
    • The subject is connected to a polygraph machine that measures and records various physiological indicators, such as heart rate, blood pressure, respiratory rate, and skin conductivity (sweat).
    • The test involves a series of questions, some of which are control questions (neutral) and others are relevant to the investigation.
    • The theory is that when a person lies, their body exhibits involuntary physiological responses, such as increased heart rate or sweating, which the polygraph detects.
    • The results are interpreted by an expert who compares the physiological responses to different types of questions to determine whether the subject is likely being deceptive.
  • Limitations:
    • Polygraph tests are controversial because they are not foolproof; physiological responses can be triggered by anxiety, nervousness, or other emotions unrelated to deception.
    • The accuracy of polygraph results is debated, and they are not universally accepted in courts as reliable evidence.

2. Narcoanalysis Test:

  • Purpose: Narcoanalysis is a psychological tool used to attempt to retrieve suppressed or subconscious information by putting the subject in a state of altered consciousness.
  • How It Works:
    • A drug, typically sodium pentothal (also known as truth serum), is administered to the subject, which puts them in a sedated or semi-conscious state.
    • In this state, the subject is believed to be more likely to speak the truth or reveal hidden memories because their conscious mind, which might normally inhibit them, is subdued.
    • The subject is then questioned, and their responses are recorded.
  • Limitations:
    • Narcoanalysis is also controversial and is criticized for its ethical implications and potential human rights violations.
    • The accuracy of information obtained during narcoanalysis is questionable since the subject is in an altered state of consciousness and may provide unreliable or fabricated responses.
    • Like polygraph tests, the results of narcoanalysis are not typically admissible as evidence in court due to their unreliability and the potential for coercion.

Legal and Ethical Considerations:

  • Both polygraph and narcoanalysis tests raise ethical and legal issues, particularly concerning the subject’s consent, the accuracy of the results, and their use in criminal investigations and trials.
  • In many countries, including India, the use of these tests in criminal investigations requires the informed consent of the subject, and the results cannot be used as sole evidence in court.

In summary, while both polygraph and narcoanalysis tests aim to uncover the truth, their reliability and ethical implications are widely debated, and they are often used with caution in legal settings.

Also Read