Universal Basic Income Explained

Universal Basic Income of (UBI) is a concept where the government provides every citizen, regardless of their socio-economic status, with a fixed, unconditional amount of money on a regular basis. The core idea behind UBI is to ensure that every individual has enough to meet their basic needs such as food, clothing, and shelter. This guaranteed income is provided without any conditions related to employment or means-testing. As a policy proposal, UBI has been gaining traction globally, especially in the wake of rising unemployment, automation, and economic inequality.

In the Indian context, the idea of UBI has been debated as a possible solution to the country’s multifaceted problems, including poverty, income inequality, and the inefficiencies of existing welfare schemes. The concept received significant attention when the Economic Survey of India for 2016-17 dedicated an entire chapter to exploring its potential, signaling growing interest among policymakers in UBI as a tool for economic transformation.

Why Universal Basic Income is Relevant for India

India, with its vast population, has a unique set of socio-economic challenges that make UBI an appealing solution. Some of the most pressing issues include:

1. Poverty: Despite notable economic progress, a significant portion of the Indian population continues to live below the poverty line. As per the World Bank, over 10% of Indians live on less than $2 per day. UBI could provide a direct and effective means of poverty alleviation, ensuring that every citizen has access to a minimum standard of living.
2. Inefficiency in Welfare Schemes: India has several welfare programs such as the Public Distribution System (PDS), Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA), and various subsidies. However, these schemes are often plagued by inefficiencies, corruption, and leakages. UBI could eliminate these inefficiencies by providing direct cash transfers to the beneficiaries, thus reducing the scope for corruption and ensuring that the intended recipients receive the benefits.
3. Income Inequality: India ranks among the countries with the highest levels of income inequality. The top 10% of the population owns more than 77% of the national wealth, while the bottom 60% owns less than 5%. A UBI could help redistribute income more equitably and create a more balanced society.
4. Automation and Job Losses: The rise of automation and artificial intelligence is expected to displace a large number of jobs, especially in sectors like manufacturing and services. In a country like India, where unemployment is already a major issue, UBI could provide a safety net for individuals who lose their jobs due to technological advancements.
5. Agricultural Distress: A significant portion of the Indian population is dependent on agriculture, which is subject to fluctuations in weather, prices, and government policies. Farmers often suffer from financial instability, leading to issues such as indebtedness and even suicides. UBI could provide a stable source of income for farmers, helping them cope with agricultural distress.

The Case for Universal Basic Income in India: Pros and Benefits

1. Reduction in Poverty and Income Inequality: One of the biggest advantages of UBI is its potential to eradicate extreme poverty. By providing every citizen with a minimum income, UBI could guarantee that no one in the country goes hungry or is unable to meet their basic needs. Additionally, by distributing wealth more equitably, UBI could help reduce the income gap between the rich and the poor.
2. Empowerment and Freedom: UBI offers a sense of empowerment to the recipients. It gives individuals the freedom to make their own choices about how to spend the money, whether it is on food, education, healthcare, or entrepreneurial ventures. This autonomy can have a positive impact on the overall well-being of individuals, allowing them to pursue activities that improve their quality of life.
3. Simplification of Welfare Programs: UBI has the potential to simplify the existing welfare infrastructure by replacing a plethora of schemes with a single, straightforward cash transfer system. The current welfare programs are often overlapping, inefficient, and marred by corruption and leakage. A universal system of basic income could streamline welfare delivery, reduce administrative costs, and eliminate the middlemen who siphon off benefits meant for the poor.
4. Boost to Consumption and Economic Growth: An increase in the purchasing power of citizens, particularly in rural areas, can lead to a significant boost in consumption. This, in turn, can spur demand for goods and services, creating new markets and opportunities for businesses. By increasing the disposable income of the poor, UBI can stimulate economic growth, especially in sectors that cater to the masses, such as agriculture, small-scale industries, and retail.
5. Social Cohesion: UBI could help reduce social tensions by alleviating the economic stresses faced by the marginalized sections of society. By ensuring that everyone has access to a minimum standard of living, UBI can reduce the disparities that often lead to social unrest and violence.

The Challenges and Criticisms of Universal Basic Income in India.

Despite its potential benefits, UBI also faces several significant challenges in the Indian context:

1. Fiscal Burden: The biggest challenge associated with implementing UBI in India is the immense fiscal cost. Providing a basic income to over 1.4 billion people would require a massive allocation of resources. For instance, if the government were to provide a modest UBI of ₹5000 per month to every adult citizen, the total cost would run into trillions of rupees annually, which would put enormous pressure on the fiscal deficit and the overall economy.
2. Inflation: A large-scale UBI program could potentially lead to inflation, especially in sectors where supply is inelastic. For example, a sudden increase in the purchasing power of individuals could lead to higher demand for essential goods such as food, housing, and healthcare, resulting in price hikes. If the supply of these goods does not increase proportionately, inflation could erode the value of the UBI, making it less effective.
3. Work Disincentive: One of the major concerns regarding UBI is that it could discourage people from working. If individuals are assured of a guaranteed income, some may choose not to engage in productive activities, which could have negative consequences for the economy. However, proponents of UBI argue that most people are motivated by more than just survival needs and would continue to work for personal fulfillment and higher income.
4. Targeting Issues: While UBI is meant to be universal, some argue that it would be more efficient to target only the poor and vulnerable sections of society. Providing a basic income to everyone, including the wealthy, may not be the best use of limited resources. However, targeting brings its own challenges, such as the risk of exclusion errors (where the deserving are left out) and inclusion errors (where the non-poor are included).
5. Political Feasibility: Implementing UBI in a country as diverse and complex as India would require significant political will and consensus. Various interest groups, including those benefiting from existing welfare schemes, may resist the idea of replacing these programs with UBI. Additionally, some politicians may prefer targeted welfare programs, which allow them to gain political mileage by appealing to specific voter bases.

The Way Forward: Pilots and Incremental Approach

Given the challenges and the scale of India’s population, it is unlikely that a full-scale implementation of UBI will happen in the near future. However, there are ways to experiment with UBI through pilot projects and incremental approaches:

1. Pilot Projects: Several UBI pilots have already been conducted in India, with promising results. For instance, the SEWA (Self Employed Women’s Association) pilot in Madhya Pradesh, which provided cash transfers to rural villagers, showed improvements in health, education, and economic activity. More such pilots could be conducted in different regions to assess the feasibility and impact of UBI.
2. Incremental Implementation: Instead of providing UBI to the entire population at once, the government could start by targeting specific groups, such as farmers, women, or the elderly. For example, a farmer-specific UBI could replace the existing agricultural subsidies and provide farmers with a direct cash transfer. This would allow the government to test the waters and gradually scale up the program based on the results.
3. Conditional Basic Income: While UBI is typically unconditional, India could experiment with a Conditional Basic Income (CBI), where recipients are required to meet certain criteria, such as enrolling children in school or attending healthcare check-ups. This would ensure that the income is not only used for consumption but also contributes to long-term human development.

Conclusion

Universal Basic Income is an idea that has the potential to revolutionize the Indian economy and society by addressing deep-rooted issues of poverty, inequality, and inefficiency in welfare delivery. However, implementing UBI in India would require careful consideration of the fiscal, economic, and political challenges involved. A phased approach, backed by pilots and rigorous evaluation, could pave the way for a more inclusive and equitable future for India.

Universal Basic Income,Universal Basic Income,Universal Basic Income,Universal Basic Income,Universal Basic Income,Universal Basic Income,Universal Basic Income,Universal Basic Income,Universal Basic Income

Also Read 

• The Rashtriya Arogya Nidhi
• bharat ki rajvyavastha for upsc
• Monkeypox क्या है
• India UAE नागरिक परमाणु सहयोग
• India UAE Civil Nuclear Cooperation
• India and the United States Relations