Caste census and caste survey Key Differences.
The caste census and caste survey are both related to the collection of data on the various castes in India, but they differ in their scope, purpose, and execution. Here’s a breakdown of each:
Caste Census
1. Definition:
- A caste census is an official government-led enumeration of the population that includes detailed data on the caste composition of the country. It involves collecting information on individuals’ caste identities as part of a national census.
2. Historical Context:
- The last comprehensive caste census in India was conducted in 1931 during British rule. Post-independence, the Government of India has not included caste data (except for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes) in the decadal censuses conducted by the Registrar General and Census Commissioner of India.
- The absence of detailed caste data in the post-independence censuses has led to demands from various political and social groups to reinstate caste enumeration.
3. Purpose:
- The primary objective of a caste census is to provide an accurate count of the various castes, sub-castes, and communities in the country. This data can be used to better understand the socio-economic status of different castes and help in policy formulation, including reservation policies and welfare schemes.
4. Controversy:
- The idea of a caste census is controversial, with arguments for and against it. Proponents argue that it is essential for creating evidence-based policies that address caste-based inequalities. Critics, however, argue that it might deepen caste divisions and lead to increased social tension.
5. Current Status:
- Although there have been calls for a caste census, particularly in the context of the 2021 Census, the Government of India has not included caste data in the national census. Instead, it has focused on enumerating only the Scheduled Castes (SCs) and Scheduled Tribes (STs).
Caste Survey
1. Definition:
- A caste survey is a more localized or regional effort to collect caste-related data. It is often conducted by individual state governments rather than as part of the national census.
2. Purpose:
- The purpose of a caste survey is similar to that of a caste census but is often limited to a particular state or region. It aims to gather data on the caste composition of the population within that area to inform local policies and welfare schemes.
3. Examples:
- Several Indian states, such as Bihar and Karnataka, have conducted their own caste surveys to gather detailed information on the caste demographics of their populations.
- In 2021, the state of Bihar conducted a caste-based survey, which was seen as an attempt to address the socio-economic disparities among different castes in the state. Karnataka also carried out a similar survey in 2015, known as the “Socio-Economic and Caste Census.”
4. Data Utilization:
- Data from caste surveys can be used by state governments to design targeted welfare programs, implement reservation policies more effectively, and understand the socio-economic status of various castes in the state.
5. Challenges:
- Caste surveys face challenges similar to those of a caste census, including the risk of reinforcing caste identities and social divisions. Additionally, there are concerns about the accuracy and reliability of the data collected, as well as the methodology used in these surveys.
Key Differences
- Scope: A caste census is a nationwide effort, while a caste survey is typically confined to a specific state or region.
- Authority: A caste census is conducted by the central government, while a caste survey is generally carried out by state governments.
- Frequency: The caste census, if conducted, would be part of the decadal national census, whereas caste surveys can be conducted independently and at different intervals by state governments.
Conclusion
The caste census and caste survey are important tools for understanding the social fabric of India and addressing caste-based disparities. However, they also raise significant questions about the implications of caste data collection and the potential consequences for Indian society.
Also Read